How to Overpay for Your Next Home

How to Overpay for Your Next HomeIt all starts with the best intentions. You have a list of all the things you want in a new home, as well as a budget that you’re going to stick to.

Almost invariably, however, home buyers fall into the same trap. They tour a home that meets those original parameters, but it’s slightly above that budget purchase price. The home buyer gets caught up in something they didn’t initially consider but realize they now must have.

The problem is, only so many homes are available with that must-have, which likely means they’re going to overpay to get it. That’s how the free market works.

Overpaying for a home can be disastrous, yet it happens just about every day. If you want to join the ranks and pay more for your next home than you should, here’s how:

Let your eye wander

When people set their must-have lists for a new home, it’s mostly a practical matter. They need this many bedrooms, these many baths, perhaps a finished basement. It’s more of what they had in their last place. For example, a family living in a three-bedroom home will have their lives complete if they could just get four bedrooms.

But temptation sets in, and home buyers see a home that’s slightly above their original price range but has a “man-cave” in the basement. A home that’s 400 square feet bigger than their current dwelling has the perfect tinge of blue in the granite countertops, and now a 600-square-foot-larger home without that blue-specked granite just won’t do.

These shiny objects cause the buyers to stray from their original commitment to spend only so much because they need just so much more. When it comes to home buying, there’s always greener grass, which is also more expensive for home sales.

Ignore the math

If you find a home that fits your original specifications but is missing those new-found desires, consider what it would cost to add them yourself. For example, if the only thing that otherwise perfect home is missing is that man-cave or blue-specked granite, do some research. Find out if you can spend $20,000 less on a similar home and pay $10,000 to bring it up to your (new) standards.

The most significant mistake overpaying home buyers make is to assume that only this one home can have this thing they want. They dismiss the idea that they can add that to an otherwise perfect home for less money.

Go it alone

This point has nothing to do with wandering eyes or amenities you didn’t even know you wanted but for which you now will pay too much. It has to do with people and negotiation.

A listing agent has a responsibility to one party: the seller. They might be super-nice to you, accommodating your every request. Offer to talk to the seller about coming off their asking price. But make no mistake, they’re bound legally to represent only that seller.

And that means the best way for a home buyer to overpay is to try to negotiate a price by themselves, with that super-friendly listing agent legally bound to represent the interests of the seller.

If the home seller has an agent representing them,  why not have a buyer’s agent to serve you and negotiate on your behalf? If you were heading into court, you’d want qualified legal representation, right? So why not get qualified real estate representation to negotiate what might be the most significant purchase of your life?

Homeownership can be great, whether you’re a first-time buyer or moving up from that first home. You know what you want (or thought you did), which is excellent, but it makes no sense to overpay because you don’t recognize what makes you a candidate to pay more than you must.

Don’t be a sucker, that is, unless you want to overpay.

Are You Thinking of Buying a Home in Dubois County?

Use our site to search homes for sale in Jasper, Dubois, Spencer, Martin and Davis counties and all of our surrounding areas. Unlike the “big name” sites out there, at Sell 4 Free Welsh Realty our site is directly connected to our local MLS and is updated with new homes every hour. By signing up for New Listing alerts you can stay on top of the newest homes for sale and get price change alerts so you can stay ahead of other buyers and beat them to the hottest deals!

Start your Home Search now

Popular Jasper Indiana Home Searches:

Newest Homes for Sale in Dubois County

View the newest homes listed in Dubois County in the last 10 days:

Unbelievable is the only word that can describe this 4 bedroom, 3 1/2 bath home built in 2024 on 13.14 acres located just 12 minutes from Patoka Lake, in Birdseye, Indiana.  If you are looking for that perfect home on acreage in the country with top of the line everything, or an AMAZING weekend getaway by Patoka, then look no further.  This custom built home features 3031 square feet of finished living space with Bosch appliances, granite counter tops, hardwood floors and tile showers that will satisfy the most particular of owners.  Enjoy the new pond, do some hunting on the surrounding wooded acres, camp on the open ground, and then clean up in the free standing outside bath house.  Wired with an alarm and security system and cameras and wired for a generator if you so choose to add one, this home has had attention to every detail imaginable.  The massive open kitchen/dining/living room lends to great entertaining.  The basement has a large overhead garage door to the living area for great entertaining / grilling / possible boat storage in the winter.  The master bedroom is on the first floor adjacent to the laundry room, and bedrooms 2 & 3 are in the lower level with the 4th bedroom on the upper level.  This magnificent home has so much to offer and is ready for immediate possession. $849,000 Active

5925 S Kyana Road Birdseye, Indiana

4 Beds 4 Baths 3,031 SqFt 13.14 Acres

Listing courtesy of Andrew Welsh from SELL4FREE-WELSH REALTY CORPORATION.

Beautifully remodeled 3 bedroom, 1 bath home in downtown Jasper. As you step inside, you will instantly appreciate all the modern touches. Painted with grey and white tones, maintenance free flooring on the main level, updated kitchen, refrigerator, range, microwave and stackable washer/dryer are included. The bathroom features a  newer walk-in shower. Two bedrooms are located on the main level and a third bedroom or bonus room is located upstairs. Covered front and back porches lend shade for those hot summer days. Spacious back yard and a place to park off the alley way are added bonuses. Walking distance to shopping, restaurants, park, public pool and library. $162,000 Active

321 W 8th Street Jasper, Indiana

3 Beds 1 Baths 1,405 SqFt 0.11 Acres

Listing courtesy of Brenda Welsh from SELL4FREE-WELSH REALTY CORPORATION.

Welcome to this impeccable 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home nestled on 1.73 Acres and Beautifully Landscaped! Step inside to find the gorgeous, remodeled kitchen and baths that add elegance to everyday living. The updated flooring enhances the flow throughout, while newer appliances make this home move-in ready. Enjoy the perks of an above-ground swimming pool with a spacious deck, ideal for summer fun and weekend entertaining. Whether you're sipping morning coffee on the charming front porch or unwinding on the private back deck, relaxation is always just steps away. The home also features a sleek concrete driveway leading to an attached 2 car garage. A partially unfinished basement provides flexible space for storage. Recent upgrades include a roof installed just 6 years ago, new windows added in 2024, and the furnace and central air system was replaced only 5 years ago—ensuring comfort and confidence in every season. Stream your favorites with High-Speed Orange County Fiber Internet. $389,900 Active

149 E State Road 56 Jasper, Indiana

4 Beds 2 Baths 3,527 SqFt 1.73 Acres

Listing courtesy of Opal Sermersheim from SELL4FREE-WELSH REALTY CORPORATION.