How to Overpay for Your Next Home

How to Overpay for Your Next HomeIt all starts with the best intentions. You have a list of all the things you want in a new home, as well as a budget that you’re going to stick to.

Almost invariably, however, home buyers fall into the same trap. They tour a home that meets those original parameters, but it’s slightly above that budget purchase price. The home buyer gets caught up in something they didn’t initially consider but realize they now must have.

The problem is, only so many homes are available with that must-have, which likely means they’re going to overpay to get it. That’s how the free market works.

Overpaying for a home can be disastrous, yet it happens just about every day. If you want to join the ranks and pay more for your next home than you should, here’s how:

Let your eye wander

When people set their must-have lists for a new home, it’s mostly a practical matter. They need this many bedrooms, these many baths, perhaps a finished basement. It’s more of what they had in their last place. For example, a family living in a three-bedroom home will have their lives complete if they could just get four bedrooms.

But temptation sets in, and home buyers see a home that’s slightly above their original price range but has a “man-cave” in the basement. A home that’s 400 square feet bigger than their current dwelling has the perfect tinge of blue in the granite countertops, and now a 600-square-foot-larger home without that blue-specked granite just won’t do.

These shiny objects cause the buyers to stray from their original commitment to spend only so much because they need just so much more. When it comes to home buying, there’s always greener grass, which is also more expensive for home sales.

Ignore the math

If you find a home that fits your original specifications but is missing those new-found desires, consider what it would cost to add them yourself. For example, if the only thing that otherwise perfect home is missing is that man-cave or blue-specked granite, do some research. Find out if you can spend $20,000 less on a similar home and pay $10,000 to bring it up to your (new) standards.

The most significant mistake overpaying home buyers make is to assume that only this one home can have this thing they want. They dismiss the idea that they can add that to an otherwise perfect home for less money.

Go it alone

This point has nothing to do with wandering eyes or amenities you didn’t even know you wanted but for which you now will pay too much. It has to do with people and negotiation.

A listing agent has a responsibility to one party: the seller. They might be super-nice to you, accommodating your every request. Offer to talk to the seller about coming off their asking price. But make no mistake, they’re bound legally to represent only that seller.

And that means the best way for a home buyer to overpay is to try to negotiate a price by themselves, with that super-friendly listing agent legally bound to represent the interests of the seller.

If the home seller has an agent representing them,  why not have a buyer’s agent to serve you and negotiate on your behalf? If you were heading into court, you’d want qualified legal representation, right? So why not get qualified real estate representation to negotiate what might be the most significant purchase of your life?

Homeownership can be great, whether you’re a first-time buyer or moving up from that first home. You know what you want (or thought you did), which is excellent, but it makes no sense to overpay because you don’t recognize what makes you a candidate to pay more than you must.

Don’t be a sucker, that is, unless you want to overpay.

Are You Thinking of Buying a Home in Dubois County?

Use our site to search homes for sale in Jasper, Dubois, Spencer, Martin and Davis counties and all of our surrounding areas. Unlike the “big name” sites out there, at Sell 4 Free Welsh Realty our site is directly connected to our local MLS and is updated with new homes every hour. By signing up for New Listing alerts you can stay on top of the newest homes for sale and get price change alerts so you can stay ahead of other buyers and beat them to the hottest deals!

Start your Home Search now

Popular Jasper Indiana Home Searches:

Newest Homes for Sale in Dubois County

View the newest homes listed in Dubois County in the last 10 days:

This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home sits on a spacious 0.93-acre lot, offering room to roam and endless potential. Inside, you'll find an open layout with plenty of natural light, functional living space, and a kitchen ready for your personal touch. Enjoy peaceful mornings enclosed porch or entertain in the expansive backyard—perfect for gardening, play, or future additions. This property offers the perfect blend of privacy and opportunity. $179,000 Pending

1756 W State Road 56 Jasper, Indiana

2 Beds 1 Baths 1,152 SqFt 0.93 Acres

Listing courtesy of ElizabethMehringer from RE/MAX Local.

Discover comfort and convenience in this beautifully maintained one-level condo, built in 2020 and ideally located near shops, grocery stores, and a variety of restaurants in Jasper. This thoughtfully designed home features an open floorplan that seamlessly connects the spacious living area, dining space, and modern kitchen — perfect for everyday living and entertaining. This condo includes two generously sized bedrooms and two full bathrooms, with a third room that could be used as a third bedroom, office, or rec room. The private owner's suite features a walk-in closet, spacious bathroom, and access to the back patio. The layout offers both functionality and privacy. Enjoy the ease of an attached one-car garage and the low-maintenance lifestyle that condo living provides. Whether you're a first-time buyer, looking to downsize, or you would prefer less maintenance, this property offers the perfect blend of location, comfort, and style. $234,700 Active

906 Reyling Drive 3 Jasper, Indiana

2 Beds 2 Baths 1,258 SqFt

Listing courtesy of Hannah Welsh from SELL4FREE-WELSH REALTY CORPORATION.

Here's Your Opportunity to Own a Piece of Holland, Indiana Storied History - The Family home of Long time well-known Holland teacher, Irene Bartelt. Nestled on over a spacious quarter acre lot is this quaint 3-4 bedroom, two full bath, brick home with yesteryear character and twenty-first century updates and amenities, including Amish updated Country kitchen (New pantry & Glass-front china cabinet), 42" X 90" Solid surface top eat-at kitchen island, Refrigerator, Stove, Microwave, & Built-in Dishwasher. Also, NEW roof shingles, replacement windows, main floor dry-wall, paint refreshment, and more. Two up-dated bathrooms with one having shower over tub; second bath/laundry combo/mudroom has walk-in shower & large closet. Two ample size bedrooms along with a dedicated office with full-wall built-ins on main floor. Second floor awaits your personal touches for two bedrooms or a Master En-suite with Double walk-in closets. Plumbing & electrical 'roughed-in' in one bedroom. Blown-In insulation added first floor and upstairs. Sewer lines recently updated to town of Holland ordinance.  Don't forget the wonderful front porch and detached garage situated on deep lot extending from Linn Street to Main Street with possession @ Closing! Let's make this your 'Forever Home'! $179,900 Active

808 W Linn Street Holland, Indiana

4 Beds 2 Baths 1,764 SqFt 0.27 Acres

Listing courtesy of Delmar Bromm from RE/MAX Local.