Featured Hot Homes for Sale in Santa Claus IN

Click on the homes below to see today’s newest homes for sale in Santa Claus.

Quick Facts

Population (2015): 42,461
Zip Codes: 47513, 47521, 47527, 47532, 47541, 47542, 47545, 47546, 47547, 47549, 47575, 47580
Median Listing Price: $170,000
Median Closing Price: $176,000
County: Dubois
School District: Southeast Dubois County Schools

Travel & Commute Times

Huntingburg: 16 mins
Jasper: 13 mins
Santa Claus: 30 mins

Things to Do

Things to Do

Featured Homes for Sale with a Finished Basement in Santa Claus IN

Explore homes with a finished basement for sale in Santa Claus, IN by clicking on the images below.

Check out this beautiful home on Lake Holly. This home features 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms. The finished basement offers an additional bedroom and bathroom. The home is in need of some TLC but has great potential for someone looking to bring their own personal touch! This home is being sold “as is.” $159,000 Active

763 W Ornament Lane Santa Claus, Indiana

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,089 SqFt 0.240 Acres

Listing courtesy of Courtnay Begle from RE/MAX REVOLUTION.

Adorable 2 Bedroom Cottage Home Nestled in the Woods! Within Walking Distance of the Boat Docks on Christmas Lake. The Home looks like a Cabin with Natural Wood Trim and Large Back Deck! $139,900 Active

831 S Carol Drive Santa Claus, Indiana

2 Beds 1 Baths 975 SqFt 0.350 Acres

Listing courtesy of ChrisHarney from KELLER WILLIAMS CAPITAL REALTY.

Beautiful cape cod style home located on the golf course in the gated community of Christmas Lake Village. Located on a quiet street this home has beautiful landscaping, a fish pond with waterfall, patio facing the golf course, and an all seasons porch to enjoy all year long! The home has been recently painted and has new flooring throughout the main floor. The main floor features kitchen dining area, living room with gas log fireplace, master suite with large bathroom, an all seasons room with both glass and screens, an oversized garage that opens to main floor laundry and a half bath. Upstairs you will find two large bedrooms and a full bathroom. the upstairs also has a huge bonus room that is currently being used as a bedroom. The home features large windows for plenty of natural light. The kitchen has new cabinets, quartz counter tops, and newer appliances that all stay with the home. The garage also has new cabinets and plenty of shelving for storage and projects. Don't miss out on this gorgeous property, it is the perfect combination of tranquility, beauty, and comfort. $364,900 Cont-First Right

441 Sleigh Bell Drive Santa Claus, Indiana

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,333 SqFt 0.357 Acres

Listing courtesy of Joanie Troutman from Key Associates Signature Realty.

With over 5,600 sq ft of finished living area, this beautiful oasis is everything you could hope for in a dream home! This stunning home located in the heart of Christmas Lake Village has so very much to offer! Custom built, features include 5 bedrooms, 5 full bathrooms, and a huge kitchen with quartz countertops and quality built Amish cabinets. The great room boasts a 12' ceiling with crown molding and an elegant ceiling to floor custom designed fireplace. The dining area is ample but cozy, with lots of natural lighting. The large master suite consists of 12' ceilings, built in corner shelving, a custom designed walk-in closet, a tiled shower with dual shower heads, a corner jetted garden tub, and a seated vanity with dual sinks. The full basement is completely finished with everything you could possibly want! There is a theater room, a game area, a kitchen area, a full bathroom, and a family/sitting area. A storm shelter is also an added feature! Venture outside where you will find a large enclosed porch, a covered patio area that includes a beautiful stoned gas fireplace and a stoned grill area. Other features include a bonus room and bathroom upstairs, a 3 car garage with built in cabinets & shelves, and an outdoor 16 x 10 shed. $825,000 Active

821 S Carol Drive Santa Claus, Indiana

5 Beds 5 Baths 5,642 SqFt 0.540 Acres

Listing courtesy of Sandra Cave from RE/MAX Local.

Featured Luxury Homes for Sale in Santa Claus IN

Explore luxury homes for sale in Santa Claus, IN by clicking on the images below.

Nestled on a sprawling 1.53-acre lot in the prestigious Christmas Lake Village. Fully furnished and thoughtfully designed, this home offers unparalleled comfort and breathtaking views of the serene lake and an extra .51 acre lot for extra privacy. As you enter through the gates of this exclusive golf course community, you'll be greeted by the grandeur of this 4-bedroom, 3 full bathrooms, and 2 half baths estate. The spacious layout is complemented by high-end finishes and a meticulous attention to detail throughout. The expansive windows allow natural light to flood the living spaces, creating an inviting and warm atmosphere. For the audiophile, a sophisticated speaker system graces both the interior and exterior, providing a seamless soundtrack to your daily life and entertainment events. The kitchen is a culinary masterpiece, featuring top-of-the-line appliances, granite countertops, and ample storage space. Entertain guests in the formal dining room or savor casual meals in the breakfast nook overlooking the lush landscape. The master suite is a private retreat with its own fireplace, ensuring cozy nights and a touch of romance. The en-suite bathroom is a spa-like haven, complete with luxurious amenities and a soaking tub with a view. The lower level of this home is an entertainment haven, offering a wet bar, fireplace in the basement den, and additional spaces that can be customized for bedrooms or transformed into a state-of-the-art home theater. The oversized 4-car garage provides ample space for your vehicles and additional storage needs. With a total of three fireplaces strategically placed throughout the home, you can unwind in warmth and style in various spaces. $1,400,000 Cont-First Right

380 S Tinsel Circle Santa Claus, Indiana

4 Beds 5 Baths 7,254 SqFt 2.040 Acres

Listing courtesy of Kelly Bolhofner from RE/MAX REVOLUTION.

With over 5,600 sq ft of finished living area, this beautiful oasis is everything you could hope for in a dream home! This stunning home located in the heart of Christmas Lake Village has so very much to offer! Custom built, features include 5 bedrooms, 5 full bathrooms, and a huge kitchen with quartz countertops and quality built Amish cabinets. The great room boasts a 12' ceiling with crown molding and an elegant ceiling to floor custom designed fireplace. The dining area is ample but cozy, with lots of natural lighting. The large master suite consists of 12' ceilings, built in corner shelving, a custom designed walk-in closet, a tiled shower with dual shower heads, a corner jetted garden tub, and a seated vanity with dual sinks. The full basement is completely finished with everything you could possibly want! There is a theater room, a game area, a kitchen area, a full bathroom, and a family/sitting area. A storm shelter is also an added feature! Venture outside where you will find a large enclosed porch, a covered patio area that includes a beautiful stoned gas fireplace and a stoned grill area. Other features include a bonus room and bathroom upstairs, a 3 car garage with built in cabinets & shelves, and an outdoor 16 x 10 shed. $825,000 Active

821 S Carol Drive Santa Claus, Indiana

5 Beds 5 Baths 5,642 SqFt 0.540 Acres

Listing courtesy of Sandra Cave from RE/MAX Local.

Welcome to 389 S Tinsel Cir W, a stunning 2-story property located in the heart of Santa Claus, Indiana. The Cape Cod style architecture lends it an air of timeless elegance while its hilltop location provides breathtaking views of the surrounding landscape. This exquisite residence, spanning a generous 5,306 square feet, is nestled on a spacious one-acre lot offering a serene lakeview setting in the gated community of Christmas Lake Village that ensures utmost privacy and tranquility while offering an array of luxurious features for your comfort and enjoyment. As you enter this beautifully remodeled property, the inviting ambiance of hardwood floors & vaulted ceilings greet you. The home benefits from oversized windows that bathe every room in natural light, enhancing the overall sense of space and tranquility. The main floor houses a spacious master suite that boasts a walk-in closet & an en-suite bath for your convenience. Stainless steel appliances & granite countertops grace the large kitchen where you can enjoy casual meals in the eat-in area or prepare for gatherings in the open formal dining room. For added convenience, a side-by-side washer and dryer are included. 1 half bath Travel upstairs & you will find plenty of room for guests - there are 4 large bedrooms, a full bath & even a bonus room with a landing that overlooks the main floor. The home further enhances its appeal with full basement access - gather with family and friends enjoying the media area or serve food and drinks from the bar. One of the standout features of this incredible property are the panaromic lakeviews it provides from sitting on top of a hill. Imagine waking up to serene water views each morning on the front porch. Outside you will also find two garages perfect for storing four vehicles - offering room for ample storage or a workout space. This impressive dwelling is located within the gated community of Christmas Lake Village that not only ensures peace and privacy, but offers a plethora of amenities from lake & beach access for boating, swimming, fishing and more. Roof replaced 2016 50 year shingles, windows replaced 2018, doors replaced, 2016 new deck $749,000 Active

389 Tinsel Circle Santa Claus, Indiana

5 Beds 4 Baths 5,306 SqFt 1.200 Acres

Listing courtesy of KaraHinshaw from Key Associates Signature Realty.

Welcome to your dream home in Christmas Lake Village in Santa Claus, IN! This spacious residence sits across an impressive 1.5 acres, encompassing four lots, providing you with the perfect blend of space and tranquility. Boasting 5 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and over 4,300 square feet of living space, this updated home offers the epitome of modern comfort. The main level and finished basement have been remodeled, featuring new LVP flooring, fresh interior paint, and a host of other upgrades. As you arrive, a spacious driveway leads to an attached 3-car garage with a workbench area. The well-kept landscaping sets the tone for the beauty that awaits within. A large covered front porch welcomes you, offering a perfect spot to relax and enjoy the outdoor surroundings. Upon entering through double doors, you are greeted by a grand foyer with tall ceilings and a striking staircase. To the left, the formal dining room showcases a beautiful chandelier and a board and batten accent wall. The completely remodeled kitchen boasts Decora cabinetry, updated stainless steel appliances, a new coffee bar and pot filler, a large kitchen island, and a breakfast bar. The kitchen seamlessly opens to the spacious living room, adorned with large windows, a ceiling fan, and a natural gas fireplace. The main floor also hosts a home office with ample storage, a half bathroom, and a remodeled laundry room. Heading upstairs, the primary suite is a true retreat with carpeting, large windows, a shiplap accent wall, and an oversized walk-in closet. The en-suite bathroom features a twin sink vanity and a stand-up shower. Two more spacious bedrooms on this floor share a full-sized bathroom with a twin sink vanity and shower tub combo. The finished walkout basement boasts a large family room perfect for entertaining. A bar with a kitchenette enhances the entertainment space. Two additional spacious bedrooms downstairs, each with LVP flooring, ceiling fans, and walk-in closets, offer flexibility and comfort. The basement also includes another fully finished bathroom with modern updates and a shower tub combo, as well as a large storage room with built-in shelving. Step outside to the upper open deck, equipped with a natural gas hookup for a grill or fireplace. The lower deck, accessible from the basement, boasts new roofing. Experience the quiet, country-like feel surrounded by trees and wildlife in this stunning Christmas Lake Village home. Don't miss the opportunity to make it yours! $585,000 Active

519 S Melchoir Drive W Santa Claus, Indiana

5 Beds 4 Baths 4,320 SqFt 1.500 Acres

Listing courtesy of TraeDauby from Dauby Real Estate.

About Santa Claus, Indiana

Just east of Lincoln State Park on Highway 231 sits the picturesque town of Santa Claus, Indiana. This beautiful town is home to one of Southern Indiana’s premier attractions, Holiday World & Splashin’ Safari, which attracts more than a million visitors each year.

One of the most notable neighborhoods in Santa Claus is Christmas Lake Village, a gated community that more than doubled the town’s population (it’s now around 2,500 people).

Houses for Sale Santa Claus Indiana

There are several styles of homes for sale in Santa Claus. Whether you are looking for a roomy ranch property with ample acreage or you want something in a tightly knit neighborhood where the people are friendly and the homes are close to each other, you will find it here.

The average home price in Santa Claus is about $235,000, although there are homes available for a great deal less (and a great deal more).

Homes for Sale in Santa Claus IN

Santa Claus Schools

Children who live in Santa Claus, IN are part of the North Spencer County School Corporation. Lincoln Trail Elementary School, Heritage Hills Junior High and Heritage Hills High School serve this town and its surrounding areas.

Santa Claus IN Homes by School

Things to Do in Santa Claus

Aside from Holiday World & Splashin’ Safari, there are plenty of things to do in Santa Claus. You can visit our historic post office, join the team of “Santa’s Elves” who reply to kids’ Christmas letters all year long, and stop by Santa’s Candy Castle.

Residents love Santa’s Stables, where you can ride horses in our pristine forests, and the Christmas Lake Golf Course, which is famed for its spectacular driving range and beautifully landscaped fairways.

Most residents travel to Evansville and Owensboro, Kentucky, for dining, shopping and entertainment on a grand scale.

Santa Claus Commute Times

Because Santa Claus is conveniently located near the junction of I-64 and Highway 231, commuting and interstate travel are usually a breeze.

From Santa Claus to:

  • Tell City: 18.5 miles
  • Jasper: 21.6 miles
  • Boonville: 24.4 miles
  • Owensboro, KY: 32.4 miles
  • Evansville: 59.9 miles
  • Louisville, KY: 72.6 miles
  • St. Louis, MO: 198 miles

Let’s Find Your Next Home in Santa Claus

We have extensive experience in Santa Claus and the surrounding areas, and we’re ready to help you find the perfect home for sale here. If you haven’t had a chance yet, feel free to explore our Santa Claus Indiana real estate listings. When you’re ready, call us or contact us online. We’ll build a custom search that lets you find your dream home quickly and efficiently.

1 Click Santa Claus IN Home Searches

Santa Claus IN Real Estate by Zip Code

Search Santa Claus IN by Price

Santa Claus IN Neighborhoods & Subdivisions