3 Easy Halloween Party Recipes to Scare your Party Guests

3 Easy Halloween Party Recipes to Scare your Party Guests

3 Easy Halloween Party RecipesHalloween is nigh upon us, and it’s time to start thinking about what fun appetizer you will be bringing to the Halloween party this weekend! Whether you are hosting or just attending, in the spirit of fun we have put together a list of some fun and easy recipes to get your creative juices flowing!

Halloween party recipes are easy to come by. So easy in fact that when you search the internet you will find THOUSANDS of them. So which ones are the easiest and quickest to make when you are in a time crunch? We can help you with that!

Shakespeare said it best in Macbeth when the three ugly witches uttered these famous words:

“Eye of newt, and toe of frog,
Wool of bat, and tongue of dog,
Adder’s fork, and blind-worm’s sting,
Lizard’s leg, and howlet’s wing,–
For a charm of powerful trouble,
Like a hell-broth boil and bubble.”

While these ingredients might not be practical (or easy to find) for your Halloween party menu, you can easily locate the ingredients of these 3 recipes:

Creepy Spider Cookies

We found a ton of Halloween Spider Cookie Recipes, some complicated and some super easy! After debating on which was least time consuming, we settled on this super easy recipe and with only 6 ingredients! For the Chocolate Malt balls and Cookies in this recipe you should make sure you have double the amount of chocolate malt balls to cookie ratio. This recipe makes 48 creepy spider cookies but you can make as many as you want!

Time to make: > 1 hour

Ingredients: 6

Servings: 48 Spider Cookies


  • 96 chocolate malt balls (we like Whoppers)
  • Dark Chocolate Frosting
  • White Frosting
  • Yellow, Red or Green Food Coloring (for the eyeballs)
  • Frosting Piping Bags
  • 2 packages of Refrigerated Sugar Cookie Dough (Store bought is easiest but feel free to make your own from scratch)


  1. Pre-heat the oven and roll the cookie dough into balls. Flatten the balls slightly and use your thumb to make a slight depression in each cookie where the chocolate malt ball will rest. You won’t add the chocolate malt balls until step 5. Bake the cookies according to the package directions. While the cookies are baking prepare your other ingredients.
  2. Frosting: Take the white frosting and mix in your choice (or choices) of eyeball coloring until you are satisfied with the color. You COULD also just buy candy eyes for this part but we thought making them would be just as easy.
  3. Fill your piping bags with the colored and chocolate frostings
  4. When the cookies are done, let them cool then lay some parchment paper out on your work space and arrange all of your cookies with enough space around them to work
  5. Pipe 2 small dots of chocolate frosting in the depression of each cookie then gently push the chocolate malt balls down into it to make the spiders body. Repeat steps 5-8 for each cookie.
  6. Next pipe 3 to 4 legs down each side of the cookie starting at the base of the chocolate malt balls and fanning outward from the top to the bottom. 3 legs work best for smaller cookies and 4 for bigger cookies so you will have to eyeball this before you begin.
  7. Pipe two round dots of the colored frosting in the middle-front of the cookie and make two eyeballs.
  8. Pipe a tiny pupil on top of the colored frosting. White works best on red eyes and black or chocolate works best for green or yellow eyes. You can even put a red pupil on yellow eyes or mix it up and make each one different!

That’s it! This easier version shouldn’t take very long to make and will have your guests oooooooing and ahhhhhing over your creativity. We recommend letting the cookies site for at least an hour so the frosting sets.

Variations: Change the eye color to Red or Green Frosting with a White dot for the pupil to give your spiders an even creepier look! You could even do a mixture of two or all three colors! Use Reeses Peanut Butter Cups instead of Chocolate Malt Balls.

Creepy Eyeball Rice Krispie Treats

We found tons of fun eyeball Rice Krispie recipes on Pinterest and just couldn’t resist including it in our post! With only 5 Ingredients you can whip this easy Halloween recipe out in under an hour!

Time to make: > 1 hour

Ingredients: 5

Servings: 30 Creepy Eyeball Rice Krispie Treats


  • 6 Cups of Rice Krispies Cereal
  • 6 Tablespoons Butter
  • 6 Cups Mini Marshmallows
  • Food Coloring – 3 colors (Use whatever colors you want – we chose Orange, Green & Purple – Neon colors are also fun!)
  • Candy Eyes (multiple sizes)


  1. Cut the butter up into slices and place the butter slices and marshmallows in a microwave-safe bowl and cook on HIGH for 2 minutes. Stir and repeat cooking 1 minute at a time and stirring in-between until the mixture is smooth. Microwave cooking times may vary.
  2. Divide marshmallow mixture evenly into 3 bowls and add your food coloring to each bowl until you are satisfied with the colors
  3. Starting with ONE color place 2 cups of Rice Krispies into a bowl and pour the marshmallow mixture on top of the Rice Krispies and start mixing! We found a wooden spoon works best. Continue mixing together until completely combined. **Make sure to do steps 4 – 6 for one color at a time before you move on to the next color. *Reserve a TINY bit of the marshmallow mixture in case you need it to help stick the Candy Eyes to the balls in step 6.
  4. Scoop out a small amount of the combined mixture in your hand and roll into balls. As you finish each ball place it on a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper on it so they do not stick. You can certainly make the balls all the same size but we found that changing up the sizes made the presentation more fun!
  5. While the marshmallow eyeballs are still tacky, press in a Candy Eye. You can use some of the leftover marshmallow mixture from step 4 if you need it to ‘glue’ it in place. Just use a toothpick to place a small dot on the Candy Eye before you press it into the Rice Krispie Ball. You can add one Candy Eye or two if you want. We even saw some with as many as 5 or 6 Candy Eyes in multiple sizes! Get creative!
  6. Repeat steps 4 – 6 with the remaining colors.

Done and Done! This easy Halloween recipe shouldn’t take longer than 30-45 minutes and will wow your guests!

Variations: Dip the balls in white chocolate and pipe on red veins on the side for a bloody look! For the eyeballs if you can’t find any Eye Candy then just use white icing for the eyes and black for the pupils!

Mummy Dogs

Everyone loves Hotdogs! These are some of the EASIEST Halloween Appetizers to make and they are always a party favorite! With 3 ingredients you can’t go wrong with Mummy Dogs!

Time to make: > 1 hour

Ingredients: 3

Servings: 8 – 10 Mummy Dogs


  • 1 can of Refrigerated Crescent Rolls (or pizza dough)
  • 8-10 Hotdogs (we like the bun length ones for better effect!)
  • Mustard, Ketchup or Candy Eyes (for the eyes….choose one)
  • Optional: Sliced Cheese


  1. Preheat the oven to 375 or you can also follow the Crescent roll package baking directions
  2. Lay the dough out flat on parchment paper and cut into approximately 40 thin strips
  3. If adding the cheese then cut each slide of cheese in half then cut each half in half (1/2 slice, cut in half so you have 4 slices) and place one slice on each hotdog
  4. Wrap multiple strips around each hotdog stretching the dough and criss-crossing pieces over each other (the cheese should be under the hotdog). Make sure near the top you leave a bigger opening so the hot dog shows through. This is where you will put the “eyes”.
  5. Line a cookie sheet with parchment paper and bake 12-18 minutes or until dough is a light golden brown
  6. Let cool and place two “eye” drops where you left the opening using ketchup, mustard or Candy Eyes

We hope you enjoy these easy Halloween Party Recipes and have a fun and safe Halloween! If you’re looking for more fun 2021 Halloween Party Recipes we recommend checking out Pinterest! Be sure to share this post with your friends and bookmark it so you can use it again for future Halloween parties!

Are You Thinking of Buying a Home in Jasper, IN?

Use our site to search homes for sale in Jasper, Dubois, Spencer, Martin and Davis counties and all of our surrounding areas. Unlike the “big name” sites out there, at Sell 4 Free Welsh Realty our site is directly connected to our local MLS and is updated with new homes every hour. By signing up for New Listing alerts you can stay on top of the newest homes for sale and get price change alerts so you can stay ahead of other buyers and beat them to the hottest deals!

Start your Home Search now

Popular Jasper Indiana Home Searches:

Newest Homes for Sale in Dubois County

View the newest homes listed in Dubois County in the last 10 days:

Welcome to this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home that’s very well maintained. The spacious master bedroom features a beautiful bathroom and walk-in closets in every room. The living room gives ample space to entertain family and friends.   Whether you're relaxing in the cozy living area, cooking in the updated kitchen, or unwinding in your private bedroom, this home offers comfort and convenience.  Located right down the road from the Dairy Barn, shopping, and close to schools, this home is a must-see!  Schedule a showing today and see all it has to offer. $119,900 Active

803 S State Road Birdseye, Indiana

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,312 SqFt 0.400 Acres

Listing courtesy of Shea Fleck from RE/MAX REVOLUTION.

Welcome to 563 Ridgeway Court, located in the picturesque Country Ridge Estates of Ferdinand, Indiana. This charming ranch home, custom-built by Kerstiens Homes and Designs, is just 4 years old and boasts 1,824 square feet of comfortable living space. Featuring a thoughtful split floor plan, this residence includes three spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms, offering both privacy and convenience.  As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by the warm and inviting atmosphere of the main living area, highlighted by beautiful laminate flooring that extends throughout. The large, open spaces are perfect for both relaxing and entertaining. One of the standout features of this home is the delightful sunroom, a bright and airy space where you can enjoy the changing seasons year-round.  The level yard is ideal for outdoor activities and gatherings, while the private backyard provides a serene retreat for relaxation. This meticulously maintained property offers a blend of modern amenities and timeless charm, making it a perfect choice for those seeking comfort and style in a peaceful neighborhood. $355,900 Active

563 Ridgeway Court Ferdinand, Indiana

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,824 SqFt 0.260 Acres

Listing courtesy of KaraHinshaw from Key Associates Signature Realty.

One-owner, quality built home by Andy Klem features a split bedroom floor plan with spacious, tucked away primary suite and 2 other bedrooms on the opposite side of the main floor.  The expansive kitchen and dining area is the hub of the home and could be opened up further to the adjacent living room.  Kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, breakfast bar, and a 10 ft walk-in pantry, plus there's a generous dining area for your whole family.  From this vantage point, you have a perfect view of the picturesque backyard, with not a neighbor in sight.  Enjoy the bonus finished living space the walkout basement has to offer and features such as higher ceilings, woodburning stove for cooler months, and the convenience of a half bath. There are multiple areas for storage and your own workshop, plus a room plumbed for an additional kitchen for future plans.  Step outside the basement and find an open patio and a recently finished covered deck addition.  The backyard is optimal for family fun and also includes a newer shed for your outdoor storage needs.  This home has been well-kept and well-maintained with new HVAC 2023, water heater 2020, newer vinyl plank flooring on main floor, routinely serviced chimney, and solid wood doors. $350,000 Active

1735 W 5th Street Jasper, Indiana

3 Beds 3 Baths 2,389 SqFt 0.820 Acres

Listing courtesy of Dara O'Neil from F.C. TUCKER EMGE.